Is It Cake? Holiday

Mikey Day Self - Host Andrew Fuller Self - Contestant Jonny Manganello Self - Contestant Rachel Bloom Self - Guest Judge Wayne Brady Self - Guest Judge Sebastian Maniscalco Self - Guest Judge Hannah Berner Self - Guest Judge Tiffany Haddish Self - Guest Judge Devon Walker Self - Guest Judge James Austin Johnson Self - Guest Judge Chris Witaske Self - Guest Judge Sasheer Zamata Self - Guest Judge Terry Crews Self - Guest Judge Punkie Johnson Self - Guest Judge